What Ought I Do?

Finding new confidence in an introductory philosophy class.

By Carlin Steere ’25
Date

In the first semester of my freshman year, I found myself sitting in the second row of Professor Rebecca Lloyd Waller’s “Introduction to Ethics” class. Because I had never taken a philosophy course before, and I had narrowly squeezed into a variety of courses on topics I was relatively familiar with, I felt completely out of my element while working through our assigned reading on Locke.

This, admittedly, was a new feeling for me. In high school, I usually had an inkling of what I was going into — the general ideas we would cover in each class. While I knew that this introductory course explored the idea of what a person “ought” to do according to the minds of prominent philosophers, I felt like I couldn’t grasp the topics as easily as the student to my right, who raised his hand with ease. Meanwhile, I kept my right hand firmly on my pen and the other on my bouncing left leg.

Two weeks into the class, still sitting in the second row, I decided that something about my mindset had to shift. There was no way that I would feel confident in my abilities as a student and learner if I came into class dreading discussions about the philosophical texts. I genuinely wanted to give this course my all, and, to do that, I knew something about the way I was going about my learning needed to change.

Nu Pi Kappa room in Ascension
Stained glass in the Nu Pi Kappa room in Ascension Hall.

My new goal, decided upon in the throne-room-esque Nu Pi Kappa room in Ascension, in the glow of the stained glass filtering through the windows, was to start raising my hand once a week — to put my palm straight into the air when I felt that I had a vague notion of the work I had read in the days before class. 

I made a promise to myself to simply absorb the information that my professor shared with the class. Rather than feeling like I needed to pick apart each and every detail, I wanted to see if becoming more comfortable with the space would, in turn, help me to be more confident in my ability to synthesize the assigned material.

As innocuous as this decision might seem to some, for me, it proved difficult. At first, I shied away from making myself heard and seen. I worried that if I didn’t sound as scholarly as my fellow classmates, that I would be perceived as someone who wasn’t meant to be there. This was absolutely not true, but it took me a few more lectures to come to that conclusion.

“I couldn’t back out of the class — I had made it this far by taking notes. I just had to settle into this newness.”

Carlin Steere ’25

Talking to my parents about my lack of knowledge in ethics, I was met with a chorus of “It’s new to you,” which, of course, it was. I couldn’t back out of the class — I had made it this far by taking notes. I just had to settle into this newness. 

By the time midterm exams rolled around in late September, I was participating more in class, and the pressure I once felt to know everything before it had been taught to me, was starting to fade away. As I scribbled my answers to short-answer and essay questions furiously onto the lined paper provided for the exam, I realized that the studying I was accustomed to doing outside the classroom, along with my newfound ability to absorb information inside the classroom, was paying off. I was able to complete each part of the exam with minimal confusion, if any. I was learning the course material while also learning to be more comfortable with not always being an expert on a topic as soon as it was presented to me.

Since “Introduction to Ethics,” I’ve taken three additional philosophy courses and am planning to take another one spring semester — enough courses, hopefully, for me to graduate this spring with a minor in philosophy.